Repricing Your Menu After the Surcharge Ban: Staying Compliant with Australian Consumer Law

Series Two, Part 2 of 3. Written for Australian café, restaurant, pub and bar operators. General business and compliance information, not legal advice. Check your own contracts with your acquirer, POS provider and advisers.

With card surcharges gone, the natural response is to lift menu prices. That is allowed. Australian businesses are generally free to set, raise or lower their prices. What the ACCC will not tolerate is misleading customers about prices, or about the reasons prices have gone up. For venues, that creates three areas to get right.

The short version

  • Weekend, public holiday, booking and service fees are not affected by the card surcharge changes.

  • Those fees must still be disclosed clearly and prominently under Australian Consumer Law.

  • Renaming a card surcharge as a “service fee” or “handling fee” does not make it lawful, and may be misleading conduct.

  • Cash or PayID discounts are allowed, but the full price must be the one you display most prominently.

  • Don’t blame the reform for a price rise that also covers other costs.

1. Weekend and public holiday surcharges still apply

The changes apply only to surcharges added because a customer pays by card. The RBA confirms they do not apply to weekend surcharges, public holiday surcharges, booking fees or service fees, and the ACCC confirms hospitality businesses can keep charging weekend and public holiday surcharges. A 10% Sunday surcharge or 15% public holiday surcharge can stay.

Existing price-display rules still apply to those surcharges. Disclose them clearly and prominently on menus, boards and ordering apps, so customers see them before they order, not on the receipt.

2. Don’t disguise a card surcharge

Changing the label on the terminal from “Card Surcharge” to “Service Fee” or “Handling Fee” does not work if the fee is still only charged when a customer pays by card. The ACCC says businesses should not try to get around the no-surcharge rules by describing a card surcharge as another type of fee, and that doing so may be misleading conduct. The test is simple: if the fee depends on how the customer pays, it is a card surcharge.

3. Payment-method discounts are allowed, with conditions

You can offer a discount for paying by cash, PayID or another method. But the ACCC says the price you display must be the full price customers pay if they don’t get the discount. You must not show only the discounted price, or make it more prominent than the full price, and the discount must be disclosed before customers order or pay.

For example, if a flat white is $5.00 by card and $4.80 in cash, the menu must show $5.00 as the price, with the cash discount clearly noted.

Be careful how you explain a price rise

If you lift prices, you don’t have to explain why. If you do, the explanation must be accurate. The ACCC says a business must not tell customers a price increase is due to the surcharge changes if it also reflects other costs, such as wages, rent or produce. “We’ve updated our prices” is safer than “Prices are up because of the surcharge ban” when both are in play.

Repricing that customers barely notice

Small, targeted rises on high-volume items usually recover lost surcharge revenue with less friction than awkward fractional prices across the whole menu. Adding 10 or 20 cents to a $4.50 coffee, or nudging popular drinks and snacks slightly, can do most of the work. Use the net margin exposure figure from Part 1 to decide how far to go.

Whatever you change, update every place a price appears: menu boards, table menus, QR-code ordering, your website and third-party listings such as delivery and booking platforms. Mismatched prices across channels are an easy way to attract complaints.

Next steps

  • Audit every printed menu, chalkboard, table sticker and QR-code ordering system.

  • Remove counter signs, receipts and terminal stickers that still mention card surcharges.

  • Check that weekend and public holiday surcharge notices are clear and prominent.

  • Make sure no “service fee” or “admin fee” in your POS is set to apply only to card payments.

  • Brief front-of-house staff on what to say when customers ask about prices or payment methods.

Want someone to run the numbers for your venue?

B&W Partners reviews hospitality payment arrangements and negotiates directly with acquirers and POS providers where pricing, fees or contract terms can be improved. Send us your last few merchant statements and we will show you your real cost of acceptance, your margin exposure and where the savings are. Get in touch. You run the venue. We run the negotiation.

Series Two: Surcharge Reform for Hospitality

New to the reform? Start with Series One, our plain-English guide to what changed on 1 October and why.

Sources

This article is general information only and is not legal, financial or tax advice. Card-network rules and regulations can change. Confirm your own position with your acquirer, payment service provider and professional advisers.

Image: Croissant via Unsplash.

Previous
Previous

Terminals, Integrated POS and Least-Cost Routing: Getting the Cutover Right in Hospitality

Next
Next

Hospitality: Why Losing a 1.5% Surcharge Hurts a 5% Net Margin